Curtainup Founder & Editor Elyse Sommer's Epilogue -- I've passed the torch for reviewing and editing new theater productions on and off-Broadway and elsewhere. However, I'll continue to sound off here with my take on Live and Onscreen Entertainment. As for Curtainup's extensive content since 1996-- it's all sill available at www.curtainup.com

Friday, October 7, 2022

blogspot blogupdate October 7, 2022

 While theaters have reopened, the news on that front has been more about once considered here-to-stay shows closing. That even includes Phantom of the Opera, which in the course of a remarkable 35 years became a must-go-to attraction, as the Statue of Liberty is for any visitors to New York. But those   tourists on which a show like Phantom has always relied  aren't  exactly back in droves nor have   production costs gone down. And so the famous chandelier has gone down at the Majestic Theater. Unless you catch one of the still-operating touring productions, the only way you can see it is at the Public Library for the Performing Arts invaluable film library. Just four months into what was to be the longest ever run of a Broadway musical, the TOFT (Theatre on Film and Tape) Archive video-recorded the production. Under the able stewardship of Patrick Hoffman, the library's archived films have always been available by appointment once a show closes. The Phantom video recording will become available for viewing in the TOFT Lucille Lortel screening room beginning February 20, 2023.

MY RECENT SCREENING EXPERIENCES: THE MORE APT THAN EVER DOWNTON  ABBEY AND CROWN SERIES
. . . AND THE DISAPPOINTING INTIMATE APPAREL OPERA


Why Rewatching Downton Abbey and The Crown is More Apt Than Ever  

The show the whole world was watching -- live in Great Britain and Scotland and on-screen the world  over -- refers, of course, to the rituals of Queen Elizabeth's burial and the ascension to the crown by her son. Undoubtedly it caused many like me to have another look at the still available Downton Abbey and The Crown. The real-life royal events somehow made both series more meaningful to   watch, whether for the first time or again.   

Since Downton Abbey is something of a miniature royal family drama, it somehow rings bells now that  didn't when the show first aired -- for example, with so many newspapers gone digital, just seeing all residents at Downton receive their own newspaper (and, thanks to all those servants, each paper is  ironed) underscores how times have changed. As for the November arrival of another Crown season,  the widely watched ending of Elizabeth's long reign is more than likely going to insure greater success   than ever for this drama's own finale.

Also timelier than ever is the second Downton movie spinoff. Initially, the movie could only be seen at theaters, but it's now available to rent or purchase for screen viewing. It's well worth seeing. Besides  showing the Crowleys to be very much in the present era, the new spinoff provides a happy ending for all the characters. That makes it exactly the sort of escape fare we all need during these more troubling than ever times. 

Why I Was Disappointed  in the Operatic Version of Intimate Apparel

I was fortunate enough to see Intimate Apparel, the play, both off and on Broadway and my  enthusiastic review of that production is still available in Curtainup's archives. Here's the link to copy and paste into your browser --http://www.curtainup.com/intimateapparel.html 

Since I was unable to attend the opera version during it's limited run at Lincoln Center's Mitzi  Newhouse Theater, its availability to screen was indeed good news. I'm glad for the chance to catch up  with it and do admire how Nottage has managed to stay true to the plot and yet cut the text enough to    allow time for the music. However, I can't say I found it as intriguingly different from the play, but  enjoyably so. I was underwhelmed by the physical production and found the score problematic -- not  melodic enough for musical theater lovers, and without the sort of arias that attract most opera  enthusiasts. Somehow, neither staging or score stirred me as I had hoped. That said, the singers, all  with opera backgrounds, are excellent and the score has its moments so  perhaps  readers more attuned to this type of contemporary musical presentation will differ with me. 

Close on the heels of the challenging Nottage opera, the Mitzi Newhouse is presenting a new play by  another much lauded playwright, Sarah Rule. Unlike Arthur Miller's ill-fated Salem characters in The  Crucible, Ruhl's Becky Nurse of Salem is billed as a comedy about a descendant of one of Salem's   witches -- albeit a dark one. It begins previews October 27 and opens on Thursday, November 21.
 

ABOUT  THE  RE-OPENING  OF THE  THEATER  

Though the final drop of the Phantom chandelier has been the most shocking closing, other shows  unable to withstand the still limited return of tourists spelled other closings before their time: My Dear  Evan Hansen and To Kill a Mockingbird the most notable examples.

Happily, some plays I and my backup reviewers were fortunate enough to see when they originally  opened are getting new limited runs on Broadway. That includes Take Me Out (Link to  review -- http://www.curtainup.com/takemeoutlond.html) and Cost of Living (Link to my  review -- http://www.curtainup.com/costofliving17.html). And Off-Broadway, Suzan-Lori Parks' Top Dog/Underdog is also getting a reboot. Here's the link to Les Gutman's review when it opened -- http://www.curtainup.com/topdog.htm

It's also good news that the much produced (justly so) Death of a Salesman is getting a new  production with its first black Willie Loman, the excellent Wendell Pierce. Performances will be at the Hudson  Theatre.

Finally, there's what's probably Tom Stoppard's last and most stirring and personal play, Leopoldstadt,  which premiered in London and begins an open-ended run at the Longacre Theater on September 17, 2022, with an October 2 opening.

At two hours and 10 minutes without  intermission, the saga of a family much like Stoppard's own is  not an easy entertainment. Though I'm no more in the mood than any of you reading this to be entertained by a tear-inducing narrative, if there were one play that I would attend in person this  coming season,  Leopoldstadt would be it.




Thursday, September 15, 2022

It's a Wonderful Life -- Without Rose-Colored Glasses


 
 It's a Wonderful Life sure beats the drum loudly for kindness and doing the right thing. In fact, in these stressful times we may not want to wait until Christmas to bask in Director Frank Capra's world, in which kindness and doing the right thing insures a happy ending. George Bailey's behavior, unfailingly putting the needs of others before his own, thus handily resolves his difficulties. And, when in the interest of dramatic tension, Capra allows George to  succumb to anger and despair, the director further insures that satisfying ending by bringing on the Angel Clarence to make George realize how important he has been to the well-being and happiness of others.

 That said, critics and viewers have blinded themselves to the less than wonderful aspects of that feel-good message.  For one thing, if other George Baileys with ambitions to explore opportunities for   education and achievements in the world beyond their hometowns opted to stay put, the world would  have lost many inventors, scientists, artists, writers, and humanitarians. Even more awful than  wonderful, the movie's Scrooge, the evil Mr. Potter managed to get away with stealing the money  without which George's bank could not survive.  At a time when we see corruption and selfish interests unchecked even in the most powerful places, Mr. Potter is a more ominous than ever presence.  

 Without Mr. Potter getting his just desserts, the town of Bedford Falls will remain something of a dead end for anyone with dreams of doing really big things. The reality is that the glow of that heart-warming holiday finale will fade. Bedford Falls will still lack the opportunities a less selfish rich man  like Potter might foster rather than manipulate.

 But as the unquestioningly embraced message about kindness and doing the right thing bringing its own rewards has a darker side, so did Frank Capra. The widely lionized filmmaker wasn't really the  liberal champion of kindness and America's little guy that everyone thought he was. He just happened  to be brilliantly able to use the George Baileys of America's heartland to create surefire audience- pleasing narratives. When he made Wonderful Life, Capra had just returned from his stint in the U.S. Signal Corps. The small-town life and virtues he defended were of the pre-war era. His return took him to Hollywood, not a small town where most citizens were not rich. In fact, Capra was a lifelong Republican who despised President Roosevelt and, like all movies made in the '40s, Wonderful Life did not address stereotypical racist casting. Neither were women likely to see any life choice more fulfilling than  motherhood.

 What's more, the film that has made George Bailey America's symbol of humanity had a very  inauspicious premiere.  And it was only the movie's over-exposure on TV,  thanks to an inadvertently   unrenewed copyright, that got people to fall in love with George and the other characters. 

Actually, when the movie first came out it was hardly a Christmas Must-See, and certainly not an   integral part of our cultural landscape. Its reception was so unimpressive that the copyright was  allowed to run out. And it was only because Hollywood studios were always on the lookout for movies  they could offer frequently and cheaply that Wonderful Life was seen so often. Viewers gradually fell   in love with George and made the movie a cultural phenomenon, something that feels permanent in our society.   

Though I've never been a big fan of the movie, I was very much a Jimmy Stewart fan so I'm not  posting this commentary because it's an awful movie. It does warrant a "thumbs up" thanks to the cast,  the well-crafted script with its full development of each character, the cinematography and the wonderful costumes. (All available in both black and white or colorized at Amazon Prime.) I just think it's time to take off those heavily rose-tinted glasses and recognize its decidedly unwonderful aspects. In fact, maybe some smart filmmaker will consider a reboot. After all, It's a Wonderful Life was Capra's reboot of Dickens' Christmas Carol, the most iconic of all Christmas tales. Now, there is a brand-new and  drastically recast Broadway  production in which Jefferson Mays will play all the characters.  Perhaps some talented filmmaker can do a version in which Mr. Potter goes to jail and an innovative rich man decides to make Bedford Falls a showcase for a thriving small town -- with thriving businesses and a topnotch college and hospital.